Saturday, December 06, 2008


David Kramer, Assistant Secretary of State in the Bureau of Democracy who visited Ethiopia.

“I didn’t go there wagging my finger intending to lecture. I went because we want to see Ethiopia succeed.” David Kramer, Assistant Secretary of State in the Bureau of Democracy, Human Rights and Labor said at the Center for Strategic and International Studies last month. The comment followed Kramer’s meeting with Prime Minister Meles Zenawi in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia. He was there to discuss the controversial law that would severely threaten civil society organizations (CSOs), non-governmental organizations (NGOs) and US government aid projects in Ethiopia..

If passed, the CSO law will severely limit organizations like Yoseph Mulugeta’s Ethiopia Human Rights Council. NGOs will have to get the state’s permission before spending money on public relations. Their judicial freedoms will be restricted. They will have to surrender confidential testimonies of abused victims. And even Ethiopians living outside the country will not be able to donate to NGOs.

“The overall effect of all these restrictions is in many ways the extinction of NGOs, particularly those that are engaged in advocacy and the promotion of peace and democracy,” Mulugeta said. He ruled out surviving on domestic funds saying, “Ethiopia is one of the poorest countries in the world and individual contributions are not much. So we will have to abandon our activities and close down.”

But the CSO law is only the latest in a series of measures taken by the Ethiopian government that shrink political space and freedom. This was the consensus amongst a panel of experts brought together to discuss “Human Rights and Governance in Ethiopia.” The speakers included, Yoseph Mulugeta Badwaza, from the Ethiopian Human Rights Council (EHCRO), Chris Albin-Lackey, Special Initiatives Researcher in the Africa Division at Human Rights Watch and Terrence Lyons, Associate Professor of Conflict, Institute of Conflict Analysis and Resolution at the George Mason University. Lasting well over two hours, the discussion was moderated by Jennifer Cooke, Director of the Africa Program at CSIS.

The US has raised many concerns over the proposed CSO legislation because of its restrictions on foreign funding and the debilitating effect it could have on most NGOs in Ethiopia. Many are unable to raise money without access to foreign funding. David Kramer said, “We raised concerns with things like the 10% threshold of foreign financing that would raise lots of questions about organizations given the dearth of funding domestically for many operations.”

The draft law also proposes a cap on administrative overheads for NGOs. Kramer said, “I quite simply don’t understand why the government is legislating how much an NGO can spend on overhead.”

Kramer raised these issues the Ethiopian government as a “friend” and “ally”. The US wants to maintain a close relationship with Ethiopia and ensure the country prospers. The US wants to see in Ethiopia a “democratic, prosperous member of the international community, fully integrated so it represents a real stable anchor in the region,” Kramer said.

Ethiopia is a key US ally in an extremely unstable region and the relationship between the two countries hinges largely on cooperation in counter-terrorism. But the US government also provides significant humanitarian assistance to the country. Then why does Washington have such little leverage with the government in Addis Ababa to make it reconsider this legislation?

Kramer replied, “We don’t want to politicize humanitarian assistance; we don’t want to politicize HIV/AIDS assistance. Those are programs we need to continue and support because life and death is at stake…[but],” he continued, “I think what we can do and need to do more of is co-ordination with the donors. Speaking collectively, we do perhaps add onto more leverage than might otherwise be the case if it’s simply the United States voicing concerns.”
Not everyone participating in the discussion agreed with Kramer.

The US foreign assistance package offers limited room for leverage, according to Lyons. Citing statistics from last year, he said, “In 2007, US assistance to Ethiopia was – 50% for HIV/AIDS, 30% for emergency food aid, 7% for child survival and malaria prevention, 1.5% for agriculture, 1.5% for economic growth, 1.5% for education and 1% for democracy and governance, said Terrance Lyons.

“You don’t get leverage that way! You can’t say “Just pass the CSO law and I’m going to throw the AIDS victims onto the street!”

Chris-Albin Lackey from Human Rights Watch, also warned that the CSO law was “a bellwether and an alarming signal about the overall direction that Ethiopia is moving in.”
He connected the trend towards a shrinking political space with some of the undemocratic, ruthless counter-terrorism measures employed by the Ethiopian government. He said the government had escaped all accountability for the major abuses and crimes committed against ordinary civilians and the trade blockade imposed in the name of counter-terrorism efforts against the Ogaden National Liberation Front (ONLF). He said, “Many believe this is just an extension of the old Ethiopian counter-insurgency strategy of draining the sea to kill the fish, as the same strategy was called during the 1980s.”

There is little or no credible information coming out of the Ogaden. The Ethiopian government denies access to most human rights groups. Lackey said the absence of information “will only be aggravated by the CSO law.” He added, “There is also an increasing tendency particularly at the local level of the state to view any and all critics as enemies and traitors.”

Listing out a pattern of abuses committed by the Ethiopian military against civilians, Lackey said the official response has been that “every single allegation is a lie. There has been no investigation and no attempt at meaningful accountability.”

He ended by rebuking the US government for not doing anything about allegations of torture, detention and murder. He said, “The very clear signal coming out of Washington has been that none of these abuses matter. Until that changes there will not be any meaningful international leverage possible around these issues.”

This article is also available on the website of the International Affairs Review, a publication of the Elliott School of International Affairs at the George Washington University.


matcher said...

This article on Ethopia is "Bouncer" over the head. Thought you will post some report on the 26/11 aftermath in Mumbai or how people are bouncing back to normal schedule.

editor said...

How are you? After a long long time, I came to this blog.



Indian By Choice said...

Hi Guys!
Just wanted to send in a quick update- India's First book on corporate blogging written by top CEO blogger Rajeev Karwal and social media researcher Preeti Chaturvedi titled "Corporate Blogging in India" was launched at the Oxford Bookstore in Delhi on the 10th of Dec. A hardback version of the book, priced at Rs 345 is available at all leading bookstores. We have created a blog for the same at Corporate Blogging in India. If you don't find a copy at some bookstore, please order the same through our website

Anonymous said...

India has 17% of the world’s population, but only about 0.8% of the world’s known oil and natural gas resources. Based on the progress visualized for India in next two decades, the power generating capacity has to increase to 400,000 MW by the year 2030 from the current 130,000 MW in India. For energy independence, Dr. Abdul Kalam's goals are that in 2030, the hydel capacity should contribute 80,000 MW, large-scale solar energy farms around 55,000 MW, wind energy 64,000 MW, nuclear power plants 50,000 MW and rest 15,000 MW through use of solid bio mass, bio fuel and municipal waste.

Dr. Manmohan Singh has added weight to Dr. Kalam's views on energy security and renewable energy. The National Common Minimum Programme has committed to develop our renewable energy potential. Indian government has launched the Rajiv Gandhi Vidyutikaran Yojana and a programme called 'Bharat Nirman', to complete rural electrification within the next 5 years. The program looks to combine power generation through thermal, hydro etc., replace diesel with bio-fuels in agricultural pump-sets and tractors, hi-tech biomass gasification for cooking and lighting, and develop frontier technologies like hydrogen and fuel cells.

The current Prime Minister, Dr. Manmohan Singh has spoken about how India’s sustained economic development is vitally dependent on the country's energy security and on the simultaneous promotion of sustainable and environment friendly energy technologies. The present government (UPA or United Progressive Alliance headed by Smt. Sonia Gandhi) has constitued the Rajiv Gandhi Akshay Urja Divas or Renewable Energy Day. The day honors the late Rajiv Gandhi's commitment to the country's energy security. There is also the Rajiv Gandhi Urja Bhawan will undertake holistic research in all forms of clean and renewable energy sources.

But Dr. Singh says it is an even bigger challenge to create public awareness about renewable energy. The industry is responding to the PM's view. For this, there is the Green Energy Summit 2009 from 4-6 March in Bangalore, for which Dr. Kalam is the Chief Patron. Green Energy Summit 2009, held in association with the Government of India (DST), the Ministry of New & Renewable Energy (MNRE), World Council for Renewable Energy (WCRE), UNEP, TERI, BEE, IREDA, Government of Karnataka, and several other governmental and bi-lateral agencies, is India’s first global summit dedicated to sustainable development, renewable energy and clean technologies:

The organisers (Saltmarch) have assembled a team of the brightest Green Energy intelligentsia from across the world to speak at the summit: Bharat Ratna Dr APJ Abdul Kalam (Former President of India), Dr. Hermann Scheer (Member of Parliament, Germany), H E Corrado Clini (Minister for Environment, Land & Sea, Italy), Dr. Christopher Flavin (President, World Watch Institute), Dr. Dan Arvizu (Director, U.S. Department of Energy's National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL)), Dr. Mohamed T. El-Ashry (Chair, Renewable Energy Global Policy Network (REN21)), Dr. Wolfgang Palz (Chairman of the World Council for Renewable Energy (WCRE)), Nitin Desai (Special Adviser to the Secretary General for the World Summit on the Information Society), Michael T. Eckhart (President, American Council On Renewable Energy (ACORE)), Dr. Marianne Osterkorn (International Director, REEEP Vienna) and several other technology experts.

The summit is covering topics including policy & framework, finance & strategy, CDM, China- Middle East-collaboration, solar, wind, fuels & transportation, green IT, energy efficiency, green buildings, small hydro, cogeneration, green buildings & architecture, environment. There is also a conclave of bankers, VCs, PE investors and aid organizations and a second conclave of Chief Secretaries, Energy Secretaries and administrators to drive and debate policy and implementation. You can see the complete program from

Nagesh.MVS said...

Nice post.Indian population is still increasing.

Work From Home